• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Casa Mia - Sparta: Authentic Italian Flavors with Friendly Service Near Lake Mohawk

Casa Mia - Sparta, located in the heart of Sparta, NJ, offers a warm, inviting Italian dining experience that blends casual charm with authentic flavors. Though it first appears as a simple pizza spot, the restaurant expands into a cozy space adorned with local historical photos and murals, creating a unique atmosphere. The menu shines with well-balanced dishes—like their thin, flavorful pizza slices and ziti—that satisfy without overwhelming. Service here stands out, described by patrons as attentive and friendly, making every visit feel personal. While prices lean slightly high, the quality and ambiance make Casa Mia a welcoming choice for both locals and visitors.

Casa Mia - Sparta at a glance

  • Address 20 White Deer Plaza, Sparta, NJ 07871, United States
  • Phone +1 973-729-6606
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant , Meal delivery , Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Casa Mia - Sparta: Reviews & Ratings

Stephen Babich Jr.
4

Its another italian restaurant. We went there for dinner with some friends of ours visiting. Food was good, server was good to. We didn't care for the stuffed artichoke, it left like just eating bread and not the artichoke it self. Not that bad prices, would go back again to try some different foods.

Marisa
4

Came here for a slice of pizza. They have really thin slices which my husband loves. I got a ziti slice. Great flavor, mild not too strong in cheese flavor or tomato, everything balanced and good. Only thing was slices could have been warmed up more. There are a couple of tables if you get slices that you can eat at adjacent to the restaraunt seating. Staff were very friendly and nice. Though very limited public parking around.

Aleksander Lehtinen
5

I had a good time here! The prices were a tad high for what I’m used to but seemed appropriate for the area. The food was actually pretty good and quickly served! The waitress was very nice, too - she deserves a good shout out. I’m not from Sparta but I used to live in a house on Lake Mohawk when I was little and it was a jarring first time back in over 20 years. And the waitress was really fun to speak with about the area and the people! She was very good and on top of things! My grandmother, who is supremely picky about restaurants, even gave the place a thumbs up. A quick quirk about this place - you walk in and it first looks like a fast pizza shop but then it actually opens up to a small but fully fledged restaurant with typical (but still nice!) murals. And on the walls are historical photos of the area. I think this is a decent place to eat if you’re looking for something fairly inexpensive and casual!

Mark Pierson
5

Me & my wife ate lunch here on Sat. 8/29/25. Food was delicious & our server , Dynasty, was awesome. Would definitely go back next time we decide to visit Lake Mohawk.

Location

  • Casa Mia - Sparta
    Casa Mia - Sparta
    20 White Deer Plaza, Sparta, NJ 07871, United States Hotline: +1 973-729-6606

Casa Mia - Sparta, nestled at 20 White Deer Plaza in Sparta, NJ, is a charming Italian eatery that offers a casual yet satisfying dining experience. Upon entering, you might first notice the straightforward pizza shop vibe, but the space quickly reveals itself as a cozy restaurant adorned with murals and historical photos of the area, adding authentic local character to your meal.

The menu shines with classic Italian dishes and notably thin, flavorful pizza slices that resonate well with both locals and visitors. The ziti slice, for example, strikes a delicate balance of cheese and tomato, not overwhelming the palate but delivering genuine Italian flavor. While some might wish the slices were served warmer, the overall taste proves to be quite enjoyable.

Casa Mia excels not just in food but also in service. Reviewers frequently commend the friendly and attentive staff who enhance the overall experience, making guests feel welcomed and well cared for. The atmosphere is relaxed and approachable, perfect for a casual dinner with friends or a quick lunch stop when exploring the Sparta area or nearby Lake Mohawk.

While prices are modest and reflect the area, the quality of the dishes and the efficient service justify the value. Highlights include traditional favorites like pizza and pasta, though some menu items—like the stuffed artichoke—may divide opinions. However, the willingness to explore other offerings and return for another visit is a common theme among diners.

For those seeking an authentic slice of Italy in Sparta, Casa Mia stands out as a dependable spot. Its blend of good food, warm hospitality, and a comfortable setting makes it a noteworthy destination for anyone wanting a taste of Italian cuisine entwined with local charm.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards